What Might Have Been, a new embuggerance

Almost fifteen years ago now (which doesn’t seem possible, but the timestamp doesn’t lie) I achieved a very, very minor form of Internet fame by discovering and naming a feisty embuggerance: a Google Scholar search result that is embuggered by the automatic metadata extraction. This one was so thoroughly embuggered that it took a four-word sequence (Embuggerance, Escalate, Feisty, Holistic) from an unrelated article, reimagined it as the name of two authors for a book review on the same page, and hence: Embuggerance, E., and H. Feisty. 2008. The linguistics of laughter. English Today 1, no. 04: 47-47. Sure enough, it’s still there, all these years later. It’s just a thing that happens sometimes with automation, not a fatal flaw with Google Scholar or anything like that.

Just today I encountered another similarly-embuggered authorship:

Been, What Might Have. “5Uyaqum Igai, An Indigenous Yugtun Writing System.” Exploring and Expanding Literacy Histories of the United States: A Spotlight on Under-Recognized Histories (2024).

Part of me wishes there were some neo-Puritan naming practice so that there could actually be a What-might-have Been out there writing articles. But it is probably fairer to the actual authors, Phyllis Morrow, Casey Jack, Montana Murphy and Joevahnta Usugan-Weddington, who are discussing the history of the Yugtun / Yup’ik writing system used in southwestern Alaska. In fact, however, it’s just part of the subtitle of the article: “What Was and What Might Have Been”. Poor Dr. Was didn’t even get a credit this time, leaving Dr. Been as the sole attributed author.

Incidentally, the 5 at the start of the title is a different kind of error – it’s the chapter number, appended wrongly in the actual printed text to the name of the writing system, Uyaqum Igai, which was named after its inventor, Uyaquq.

An example of the Lord’s Prayer in Uyaqum Igai

Unknown's avatar

Author: schrisomalis

Anthropologist, Wayne State University. Professional numbers guy. Rare Words: http://phrontistery.info. Blog: http://glossographia.com.

Leave a comment